LocaliQ alternatives: who else can run your ads
What LocaliQ does well for local advertisers, and how doing it yourself, a freelancer, an independent agency or Beyaoshy compare before the fall budget.
September is when the fall budget gets set. Heating companies are switching their ads from cooling to furnaces, dental offices are planning for the year-end insurance rush, and remodelers are deciding how hard to push before the holidays slow everything down. It is also when owners who have been with the same ad provider for a while ask whether they should shop around.
LocaliQ comes up often in those conversations. It is the local marketing arm of Gannett, the newspaper group, and it grew out of ReachLocal, one of the older names in search advertising for small businesses. The reasons owners give us for looking around are usually about fit rather than anything going wrong: they want a smaller team, a different style of reporting, or ads managed together with the rest of their marketing. This post covers what LocaliQ does well and how the realistic alternatives compare.
What LocaliQ does well
LocaliQ serves local businesses nationally, and scale is at the heart of its pitch: a provider that sees campaigns across many advertisers in the same category and the same kind of market. It also has its own technology for tracking calls and leads and presenting results to owners who do not want to live inside Google Ads.
Its range goes well beyond search ads: social advertising, SEO, websites, listings and reputation tools. For an owner who wants one national company to handle the whole package, with a representative who calls in and a platform to log into, that is a reasonable way to buy. Being part of a large media company also brings a kind of stability that matters more than people admit.
What varies is the detail: whose name the ad accounts are in, what the reporting counts as a lead, how the budget splits between media and management, and how the agreement ends. Ask for all of that in writing. The answers differ by product and they are the things that decide whether any provider is right for you.
The realistic alternatives
Running Google Ads yourself
Plenty of owners run a perfectly good search campaign on their own. You keep full control, you learn exactly what people search for, and nothing sits between you and the account. The cost is time and a learning curve that never quite ends, because the platform changes its defaults often, and several of those defaults spend money in ways a busy owner will not notice. Local Services Ads are worth a look for eligible trades whichever way you go; Google is tightening verification for them and moving to require a linked Business Profile, so get that tidy first.
A freelance specialist
A good freelancer can be excellent value: one experienced person, working directly in your account, who knows your campaigns inside out. The risk is concentration. If they get busy, fall ill or take a full-time job, the account waits. Freelancers also tend to be specialists in the ads themselves rather than the tracking, the website and the CRM around them.
An independent agency
A smaller agency, local or remote, sits between the two. You get a team with a bench, usually more say in how the account is run, and often a named person who knows your business. Independents vary a great deal in size and skill, so the vetting is on you.
Comparing the options
| LocaliQ | Doing it yourself | Freelancer | Independent agency | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Suits | Owners who want a national provider and a packaged approach | Owners with time who want total control | Businesses that want one expert in the account | Businesses that want a team and more say |
| How the work gets done | Account teams using LocaliQ’s own platform and tools | You, in Google Ads | One specialist | A small team with shared coverage |
| Account ownership | Ask in writing whose name the ad account is in | Yours | Ask; it should be yours | Ask; it should be yours |
| Reporting | Through LocaliQ’s platform; ask what it counts | Google Ads and whatever you build | Varies by person | Varies by agency |
| Continuity | A large organization behind the account | Depends on your calendar | Depends on one person | Depends on the size of the team |
| Ask before choosing | Ownership, reporting, the media and management split, exit terms | Whether you will still have the time in January | Who covers the account when they are away | Who actually works on the account day to day |
Pros and cons
LocaliQ
- Pro: national scale, a long history in local advertising and its own tracking technology.
- Pro: a wide range of channels under one provider.
- Pro: stability from being part of a large company.
- Con: a packaged approach may give owners less direct say in campaign details than they want.
- Con: ownership and reporting terms need to be checked product by product.
Doing it yourself
- Pro: complete control and the fastest learning about your own customers.
- Con: the time cost is high and the mistakes are quiet.
A freelancer
- Pro: direct access to an expert, often at good value.
- Con: everything depends on one person’s availability.
An independent agency
- Pro: a team, a named contact and room to shape the account.
- Con: quality ranges widely, so check references and ask to see a live report.
Which option fits which business
- An HVAC company heading into furnace season with a small, tight search campaign. Doing it yourself or a freelancer can work well if someone checks the search terms weekly.
- A dental practice that also needs listings, reviews and a better website. A provider that handles all of it together, whether LocaliQ or an independent agency, saves coordination.
- A remodeler who wants signed jobs fed back into the ad account. You need someone comfortable with offline conversions and the CRM, which narrows the field to specialists who do that routinely.
- A med spa owner who wants to see every setting. Choose an arrangement where the account is plainly yours and you have full access.
One more name for the list
Beyaoshy is an independent option built for owners who want the ads connected to everything around them. The same team manages Google Ads, Local Services Ads, the Business Profile, local SEO, review requests, the website and the CRM that catches the leads, so when a call comes in from an ad we can follow it all the way to a booked appointment and report that, not just the click.
We have worked with local businesses since 2015. Other marketing agencies white-label our work and put their own brand on it. The ad account, the analytics and the tracking numbers are registered to you from the first day, and you get the whole team without hiring one yourself.
Before the fall budget is locked
Whoever you choose, get three things in writing: whose name the accounts are in, what counts as a lead in the reports, and what happens to your campaigns and numbers if you move on. Compare those answers before you compare anything else. You can see how we handle Google Ads and how it connects to local search, or start from our page for local business owners.
Written September 11, 2024, and kept as written. Platforms, features and policies mentioned here are described as they stood at the time.
Google Ads is part of what we run for clients.
This was written in September 2024, and the platforms have moved on since. We will check where your business stands today and tell you what to do first.