On Tuesday at I/O, Google announced that AI Overviews are rolling out to everyone in search, not just to people who opted into the Labs experiment we have been watching for the past year. By Wednesday morning they were showing up in the accounts we run, on queries that used to be a straight list of three listings and a map.
The week was noisy for other reasons too. OpenAI put out GPT-4o the day before, and half the marketing newsletters in your inbox spent Monday on that. This is the one that actually changes what a patient or a homeowner sees when they search for you, so this is the one we have been pulling apart.
What it looks like on a local search
Two days is not enough to talk about traffic. It is enough to sit with a browser and look, which is what we have been doing across dental, med spa and home services accounts.
A few patterns so far.
Purely navigational searches are untouched. Somebody typing your practice name still gets your listing and your site, and no summary appears at all. That is most of your branded volume and it is fine.
Broad research questions are where the summary shows up hardest. “Is a dental implant worth it”, “how long does a crown last”, “what does a mini split cost to install”. These get a paragraph, a few bullets, and links out to the side. If you have been writing patient education pages to catch that traffic, expect fewer clicks off those queries.
The “near me” searches are a mixed picture. On plenty of them there is no summary and the map pack sits where it always did. On others a summary appears above everything, describes what to look for in a provider, and then the map pack follows underneath. The listings did not move. They moved down.
Where the early answers go wrong
We check the answers Google gives about our own clients before we tell anyone what to do about it. Some of what comes back is fine. Some of it is not, and the failures rhyme:
- Old hours and old services. One practice stopped taking a plan last year, removed it from the site, and the summary still says they take it. The source was a directory page nobody has updated.
- Two businesses merged into one. Similar names in the same metro, blended into a single description with the wrong phone number attached.
- A price that was never on the site. Pulled from a national average article and presented as though it were local.
- A closed location. Not on the profile, not on the site, still living in an aggregator.
- Confident answers to clinical questions that a dentist would not phrase that way. Not our problem to fix, but worth knowing what a patient read before they called.
The pattern underneath all of it: where your own pages are thin, out of date or silent on a question, something else fills the gap, and the something else is usually a directory you do not control.
What actually feeds these answers
There is no separate lever to pull. The summary is built from the same web Google already indexes plus what it knows about your business, so the inputs are the ones you already had:
Your profile. Hours, services, categories, the description, the attributes. Google has been leaning on profile data for local answers since long before this, and it leans harder now. A profile with an accurate service list is doing more work this month than it did last month.
Your own pages, written in a way that answers the question directly. Not a 2,000 word essay with the answer buried in paragraph nine. A clear heading that asks the question the way patients ask it, followed by a short, specific answer, then the detail. That format was good for featured snippets and it is good for this.
Your reviews, and your replies to them. Review text is public writing about your business that you did not write, which makes it exactly the kind of source a summary reaches for.
Consistency across directories. The stale listing you ignored because it sent no traffic can now be quoted back to a patient in a sentence that looks official.
One related note: Google began enforcing its site reputation abuse policy on the 5th, aimed at the coupon and “best of” sections that big publishers rent out to third parties. If some of your category’s directory pages thin out over the next few months, that is why. Do not count on it. Fix your own entries.
What to do this month
- Search your own top five questions and your top three “near me” phrases, signed out, and screenshot what comes back. You want a record of what this looked like in May.
- Read any AI Overview that mentions your business word by word. Note every fact that is wrong and where it plausibly came from.
- Fix those sources in order: your website, your Google Business Profile, then the directories, then the aggregators feeding the directories.
- Pick your ten most common patient or customer questions and give each one a clear heading and a direct two sentence answer on your own site.
- Check your analytics for the pages that live on informational queries and note where they stand now, before the picture blurs.
- Do not panic about the map pack. It has not changed. It is further down some pages.
The thing nobody can tell you yet is how this settles, and anyone giving you a percentage two days in is making it up. What we do know is that the inputs have not changed, they just count for more. That means AI search visibility work looks a lot like the local search work we were already doing, with more attention on which sources are speaking for you. If you only do one thing this month, make it your business profile, because it is the fastest thing to correct and the most often quoted.
Written May 16, 2024, and kept as written. Platforms, features and policies mentioned here are described as they stood at the time.
Where answer engines get local recommendations
Run the same fifteen prompts through two engines, log who is named and what is cited, and you will find the records quietly answering on your behalf.
ReadThe mid-year audit of your local presence
Half the year is gone. The profile fields, listings, photos, hours and unanswered questions we go back over in July, in the order we work through them.
ReadReviews under enforcement: fix your flow
The fake reviews rule has been in force since October 2024. Incentives, staff reviews, AI-written replies, and the review flow we build to stay clear.
ReadThis is what we do for clients: AI Search.
The platforms have moved on since this was written. We will show you where your business stands right now and what to do first.