Email marketing for small business: what to send, how often
Four emails worth sending to past customers, how often to send them, what CAN-SPAM requires and the Gmail and Yahoo rules for reaching the inbox.
Mid-November is when we see local businesses send one holiday offer to every address they have ever collected, and in the accounts we run it is the send that goes wrong most often. Google’s sender FAQ says close to 5,000 messages to personal Gmail accounts in a day makes you a bulk sender for good, held to stricter rules.
The 60-second version
- Send four kinds: a reminder when the job comes due, a seasonal offer, a review ask after each job and a check-in with people who stopped opening.
- Reminders on the job's own interval, offers by season or monthly at most, an old list in small batches, never one blast.
- CAN-SPAM's requirements, unchanged in 2025 and 2026: honest sender details, a truthful subject line, an ad label, your postal address, a working opt-out.
- Meet Gmail and Yahoo's bulk rules at any size: SPF, DKIM and DMARC on your own domain, one-click unsubscribe, complaints under 0.3%. Outlook.com asks for the three records above 5,000 a day.
Which emails are worth sending to past customers
These four, each with its own job:
- The reminder. A note when the job comes due again. The FTC’s CAN-SPAM guide says that in a mixed email “the primary purpose of the message is the deciding factor.” Our reading: confirming a visit already booked is transactional; “you’re due, book now and save” to someone with nothing booked is marketing, so it carries the ad label, your address and the opt-out.
- The seasonal offer. One offer per email, sent ahead of your busy season. One offer is our practice, not the law; the law’s part is a subject line that matches it.
- The review ask. Google Business Profile Help suggests putting your review link “in thank you emails”. Send it to everyone, with nothing offered for it: Google bars selectively soliciting positive reviews and calls any incentive for a review “fake engagement”, and the FTC’s rule at 16 CFR 465.4 bans rewards tied to a review’s sentiment.
- The check-in. A short “still want to hear from us?” to people who stopped opening. Yahoo advises “a reconfirmation email to inactive subscribers periodically,” and Google says to “consider unsubscribing recipients who don’t open or read your messages.”
Google’s sender guidelines add: “don’t include promotions in sales receipt messages.” Our reading of the reminder rule is not legal advice; confirm with counsel.
How often to email without getting marked as spam
Predictably, never in bursts. Google says “Avoid sending email in bursts,” and Yahoo warns that a sudden spike “could get flagged as a compromised sender.” A three-year-old list mailed in one go at Thanksgiving is that spike. Google’s sender FAQ also asks for a spam rate below 0.1%, never 0.3% or higher, which is about 3 reports per 1,000 emails.
Neither Google nor Yahoo puts a number on how often to send. Our rule of thumb: reminders on the job’s own interval, yearly for a furnace, and offers by season or monthly at most. Your customers can see how often you send: since July 2025 Google has been rolling out, in select countries, a Gmail view ranking senders by recent volume, with one-click unsubscribe.
What CAN-SPAM requires in every marketing email
Five things in the email itself, unchanged since 2008: eCFR prints the CAN-SPAM rule, 16 CFR Part 316, as published on May 21, 2008, with no amendment since. From the FTC’s compliance guide:
- Honest headers. From, To and Reply-To identify you.
- A truthful subject line. It “must accurately reflect the content of the message.”
- An ad label. Say clearly that the email is an ad. The CAN-SPAM Act waives this where recipients gave prior affirmative consent, so past buyers who never signed up differ from subscribers.
- Your postal address. A P.O. box registered with the Postal Service counts, handy for a mobile groomer.
- A working opt-out. Act on requests within 10 business days; keep the link working for at least 30 days after the send.
The guide adds that hiring a platform or agency does not move the responsibility, and that each violating email can cost up to $53,088. Not legal advice; ask counsel whether your list counts as consented.
What Gmail, Yahoo and Outlook check before your email lands
Proof the mail is yours, an easy exit and few complaints. Since February 1, 2024, Google has required every sender to Gmail to use SPF or DKIM, valid DNS records, TLS and a spam rate under 0.3%. Bulk senders also need SPF and DKIM together, DMARC (a “none” policy is fine), an aligned From address and one-click unsubscribe. Since November 2025, Google’s FAQ says, mail that misses “will experience disruptions,” including “temporary and permanent rejections”.
Yahoo’s Sender Hub enforces nearly the same list but says “We will not specify a volume threshold,” so we tell owners to meet the bulk standard at any size. Since May 5, 2025, Outlook.com has required SPF, DKIM and DMARC from domains that send it more than 5,000 emails a day.
| Who sets it | Unsubscribe deadline |
|---|---|
| FTC, under CAN-SPAM | 10 business days |
| Google, for Gmail | 48 hours, recommended |
| Yahoo | 2 days, via a List-Unsubscribe header; a footer link alone fails |
Whatever sends your mail, a newsletter tool, a CRM or your booking software, ask if it sends from your domain with SPF, DKIM and DMARC, adds one-click unsubscribe, drops an opt-out from every list and prints your address. When we build a GoHighLevel CRM, we set up its sending domain, so the reminders and review asks it sends go out from your own domain.
Why a bought list fails both tests
Inbox providers forbid it, and the law still holds you liable. Google says “Don’t purchase email addresses from other companies,” and Yahoo “Don’t purchase mailing lists”. CAN-SPAM does not ban buying one, but it bars selling the address of anyone known to have opted out. It also makes an email that already breaks its rules an aggravated violation when the address was scraped from a website that promised not to share it, or generated by software; a purchased file cannot rule out either. Ask counsel first; this is not legal advice.
What to do this month
- Split your list into customers from the last 12 months and everyone older; mail the recent group first, in small batches.
- Send marketing from your own domain, not a personal Gmail account (Google says it errors past 500 emails a day), and have your domain manager confirm SPF, DKIM and DMARC.
- Move the coupon out of receipts and reminders into its own email.
- Verify your domain in Google Postmaster Tools and read the spam rate after each larger send; Google says the dashboards can miss data on low-volume days.
Texts, calls and the win-back sequence are in our playbook on keeping customers coming back. For a free plan, tell us where your customer list lives and which of the four you send now; we will say which to start, which to fix and whether your domain is ready.
You made it to the end. Now let's get you more customers.
GoHighLevel Buildouts is part of what we set up and run every day, along with the search, ads and follow-up around it. Tell us about your business and we will send back what to fix first.
- A free consult. A real conversation about your business, your area and what is not working yet.
- An honest evaluation. Where you stand in search, ads and follow-up next to the businesses you lose customers to.
- A plan you keep. What we would fix first and why. It is yours whether or not you work with us.
Form not loading? Email hello@beyaoshy.com and we will reply within one business day.